THE SCORECARD

Model scorecard

In AutoDev LG, several local LLMs split the work. Who works the most, what are they good at, what do they struggle with? Counted from the records of every run.

Turns: times a model was loaded to handle one job. Test-writing pass rate: share of test-writing turns that didn't end in "couldn't write the tests" (retries count separately). PASSes closed: times it was the coder when the run PASSed.

Qwen3.8-Flash-Next

MoE

The hard-working captain. Shows up almost everywhere, from requirements and design to coding. Of 18 PASSes, it closed 17. 141.7 hours of work — nobody else comes close.

104
runs appeared in
360
turns
141.7h
hours worked
84% (121/144)
test-writing pass rate
17
PASSes closed
10
reviews
Roles played
Test writing / design follow-up 154, Leader (requirements, design) 100, Coding 82, Coding (resumed) 11

Gemma-4-26B-A4B-it

MoE

The review machine. 231 checks done, and it appeared in more runs than any other model. Ask it to write tests, though, and it passes only 39% of the time.

113
runs appeared in
297
turns
19.4h
hours worked
39% (12/31)
test-writing pass rate
0
PASSes closed
231
reviews
Roles played
Test review 139, Test-plan review 92, Test writing / design follow-up 31, Leader (requirements, design) 14

Qwen3.8-27B

Dense

The test-writing craftsman: 81% pass rate. Short, sharp turns — only 3.3 hours of work in total.

37
runs appeared in
86
turns
3.3h
hours worked
81% (55/68)
test-writing pass rate
0
PASSes closed
9
reviews
Roles played
Test writing / design follow-up 73, Rewritten-test review 9, Test rewrite 4

gpt-oss-120b

MoE

The last line of defense — the backup called in when the others get stuck. 73% pass rate at writing tests.

9
runs appeared in
24
turns
0.9h
hours worked
73% (11/15)
test-writing pass rate
0
PASSes closed
6
reviews
Roles played
Test writing / design follow-up 15, Test review 6, Rewritten-test review 2, Test rewrite 1

Qwen3.6-27B

Denseretired

The retired previous test-writer. Handed over to Qwen3.8-27B after 9/24. 68% pass rate.

23
runs appeared in
41
turns
3.4h
hours worked
68% (23/34)
test-writing pass rate
0
PASSes closed
0
reviews
Roles played
Test writing / design follow-up 39, Leader (requirements, design) 1, Design reconciliation 1

Qwen3.8-27B (IQ3_S)

Denseretired

Worked as the coder just 4 times early on, then retired. But it's the model that landed the very first PASS on 9/14.

4
runs appeared in
4
turns
0.9h
hours worked
—
test-writing pass rate
1
PASSes closed
0
reviews
Roles played
Coding 4

Counted from every run's per-turn records (escalation-chain-run.json). Hours worked include model loading time.